Proof Portal
Project overview
Omarchy
ProbeLabs73 findings · 87 requirementsA proof layer — requirements, tests and verified fixes — for two of Omarchy's subsystems: the application menu (launcher scripts, QML model, JSONC config, search and selection) and the lock screen (lock scripts, QML, PAM authentication). Scope is deliberately limited to those components of omacom/omarchy; the rest of the distribution is not covered.
Audit history
Run · 7e54103
Audited Oct 3, 2026, 12:13 AM on quattro-proof.
Verified
85/85 realizable87/87 meet policyverification complete: 3
as of 7e54103 · Oct 3, 2026 · quattro-proof
Run context
What was audited, and where.
Branchquattro-proof
Commit7e54103
RecordedOct 3, 2026, 12:13 AM
Tags—
Checks
This run's checks — open one for its full detail in the current audit.
- acceptance_criteria_witnessedPass3 testable acceptance criteria across 2 stakeholder req(s) witnessed (3 via direct acceptance test)
- acceptance_witness_qualityPassno :acceptance tags share a test carrier with a derived SYS/SW/INT witness
- accepted_risks_reviewedPassno active accepted risks
- ambiguity_reviewedPass0 ambiguous pairs (2355 pairs checked)
- annotation_validityPassall referenced requirement IDs and obligation annotations match current spec files
- approval_motivation_presentPassall 0 approved requirement(s) carry valid motivation (or are initial-creation exemptions)
- approvals_currentPassapproval policy disabled
- approved_guarantee_ki_conflictPassno approved guarantee conflicts with an unacknowledged open known issue
- assume_contract_consistencyPassno reqproof:assume directives found; assume_contract_consistency passed
- assumptions_statusPassno active assumptions
- authored_delta_expectedPassall traced production implementation files have current no-authored-change reviews
- autolink_cleanPass0 autolink errors
- behavioral_implications_verifiedPassno variables with Z3-backed properties or constraints to verify
- build_matrix_completeSkipno build_targets declared (build matrix check opt-in)
- build_passesPassfor f in bin/omarchy-apply-lock bin/omarchy-system-lock bin/omarchy-update-lock bin/omarchy-hyprland-session-locked bin/omarchy-system-sleep-lock bin/omarchy-menu bin/omarchy-menu-select bin/omarchy-menu-input bin/omarchy-menu-plugin bin/omarchy-menu-share bin/omarchy-menu-timezone bin/omarchy-menu-file bin/omarchy-menu-emoji-insert; do /usr/bin/bash -n "$f" || exit 1; done; node --check shell/plugins/menu/MenuModel.js (ok)
- catalog_completenessPasscatalog/obligation/signal/requirement set is internally consistent (18 obligation_class(es) declared, 327 catalog class(es) loaded)
- catalog_semantic_bindings_reviewedPassno semantic-scan artifact
- catalog_version_pinnedPasscatalog version pin "1.11.0" matches shipped 1.11.0 (policy=manual)
- change_evidence_completePassevery in-branch-changed change-typed review has complete backing evidence
- change_record_landsPassno CHG / DEFECT records declared affects: (nothing to cross-check)
- changed_requirements_reviewedPasschanged requirement review skipped (no git diff context)
- circular_deps_cleanPass0 circular dependencies
- code_mcdc_coveragePasscode-level MC/DC meets configured thresholds (aggregate decisions 100.0%, conditions 100.0%, 0 incomplete functions) (63 ignored decisions)
- code_mcdc_measurePasscode-level MC/DC evidence available for: bash, js, qml
- code_predicates_modeledPassall load-bearing code predicates on 70 implemented FRETish requirement(s) are modeled or explicitly not_modeled (69 empty-decision mutex leaf/leaves)
- code_signal_deadline_cast_unreviewedPassno proof/signals directory (deadline-cast signal hunt no-op)
- code_signal_obligations_reviewedPass4 code signal(s) across 4 source artifact(s); explicit signal obligations covered or explicitly resolved
- code_signal_suppressions_reviewedPassno project signal suppressions declared
- code_signal_unbindablePass4 code signal(s) across 4 source artifact(s); no proposes_class declarations are unbindable
- concern_adjudicatedPassno concerns directory (concern adjudication no-op)
- consistency_pair_coveragePassall 4 components with >=2 formalized guarantees have checkable consistency pairs or recorded justification (4 zero-checked: 4 attested)
- contract_alignment_cleanPasspublic command surfaces have aligned requirement/help/test coverage
- coverage_metPass100% coverage (87/87)
- coverage_thresholdPassno requirements with coverage data to check
- cross_component_cleanPass0 cross-component reqs fully covered
- cross_level_completePass100% cross-level coverage (2/2)
- cross_spec_consistency_cleanPass0 cross-spec contradictions (0 pairs checked)
- cvss_severity_consistentPass0 CVSS-carrying known issue(s) label at or above their own vector band (or carry a reviewer-stamped severity_bound)
- data_constraint_z3_coveragePassno variables with Z3-backed properties or constraints to check
- data_constraints_completePassno variables with Z3-backed properties or constraints to verify
- decomposition_reviewedPass0/0 decompositions complete; 14 parent(s) state their own verified claim and are refined, not decomposed
- defect_review_currentInfo17 stale, 0/17 specs: claim-reviewed, 0 verified, 0 promoted, 0 dismissed
- deletion_without_retirementPassno baseline available, skipping
- deployment_tvl_verifiedPassproject is not Web3/DeFi — deployment_tvl_verified skipped (enable via checks.deployment_tvl_verified.enabled: true)
- description_delta_reviewedPassno changed requirements in current branch
- description_grammar_enumeration_completeSkipdisabled by project.checks policy
- differential_conformancePassno differential fixtures under proof/fixtures/ (author one with schema proof.fixtures/v1)
- disclosure_safePassno active known issues carry a `private` or under-embargo disclosure
- documentation_coverageSkipdisabled by project.checks policy
- documentation_enforcedPassdocumentation.enforce_sources not configured (check disabled)
- documented_claim_verifiedSkipno documented_behaviors declared (documented claim evidence check opt-in)
- dual_path_guards_equivalentSkipno dual-path rules declared in proof/dual-path-rules/ or project.dual_path_rules (dual-path guard check opt-in)
- evidence_diversityPassevidence diversity policy disabled
- failing_test_blocks_approvalPassno approved requirement is witnessed only by a failing or skipped test
- fixture_staleness_cleanPassno components declare fixture-backed evidence -- fixture staleness not applicable
- flip_fixtures_existPassno components declare fixture-backed evidence -- FLIP fixtures not applicable
- flip_test_alignmentPassno components declare fixture-backed evidence -- FLIP test alignment not applicable
- formalization_lemma_verdict_consistencyPassno SYS-REQ claims formalization_status=valid with a LEMMA: trace or verifies: annotation
- fuzz_evidence_carrier_validPassno :fuzz annotations in scope
- gaps_cleanPass0 unconstrained outputs
- high_severity_obligation_without_vectorPass1 high/critical ObligationHazard class(es) covered by vector related_obligation_classes
- high_severity_reproducer_gradePass2 active high/critical-severity or security-relevant (cve_surface possible/likely/confirmed) known issue(s) carry severity_basis=reproducer + a resolving evidence_manifest
- integration_evidence_witnessedPassno active integration requirements to witness
- interface_contract_duplicatesPass0 duplicate interface contracts
- interface_coveragePassall 1 interfaces covered
- interface_formalization_completePassno configured cross-component specs require FRETish formalization
- interface_staleness_cleanPass1 interface contracts checked, 0 stale
- known_issue_affected_requirements_presentPass73 active known issue(s) name the requirement(s) they violate (or carry a reviewer-stamped requirement_exemption)
- known_issue_closure_platform_boundSkipno known issue declares `platforms:` (platform-bound closure check opt-in)
- known_issue_completePass73 active known issue(s) meet the quality floor (evidence attached; severity-scaled core fields present; no dedup matches against prior-audit / sibling KIs)
- known_issue_mirror_anchor_relevantPass0 active known issue(s) with a declared mirror anchor have affected_requirements that fall inside that mirror's scope (or resolve to no scope / are waived)
- known_issue_platform_coverageSkipno build_targets declared (platform coverage check opt-in)
- known_issue_poc_quality_effectivePass2 high/critical known issue(s) with a poc_quality block satisfy every applicable rule (or carry a reviewer-stamped poc_quality_exemption)
- known_issue_recheck_duePassno known issues are overdue for upstream re-check
- known_issue_reproducer_consistentPass73 active known issue(s) with a bound reproducer assert the secure contract or declare a characterization (no reproducer contradicts its finding)
- known_issue_reproducer_present_and_resolvesPass73 active known issue(s) carry a runnable reproducer (a resolving test selector, a runnable command, or a `// Reproduces:` annotation) or a reviewer-stamped poc_presence_exemption
- known_issue_security_remediation_presentPass0 security-relevant known issue(s) document a remediation or mitigation (or carry a reviewer-stamped remediation_exemption)
- known_issue_severity_prose_consistentPass0 known issue(s) with a prose severity grade match their structured severity field (or carry a reviewer-stamped severity_bound)
- known_issue_sibling_dispositionPass73 known issue(s); none fixed with template_class, kill_domain, or isomorphic_sites to checklist
- known_issue_template_transferPass73 open known issue(s) meet template-transfer hygiene
- known_issues_reviewedPass73 active known issue(s) visible (review interval 90 day(s))
- l0_stakeholder_completePass2 STK-REQs fully structured (persona, story, acceptance criteria with derived_reqs)
- l1_system_completePass15 SYS-REQs fully linked and described
- l2_software_completePass70 SW/INT-REQs fully linked to SYS-REQs
- lemma_binding_freshnessSkipno separate-file lemma bindings recorded yet — run `proof verify-lemma` on a package with import-attached `// reqproof:lemma ... binds-to ...` directives to populate
- lemma_branch_coverageSkip0 reqproof:lemma annotations in project — coverage not applicable until lemmas are authored
- levels_connectedPassall 3 spec levels connected (L0:2, L1:15, L2:70)
- lint_cleanPassall functions traced
- mcdc_coveragePass85 requirements checked, 311 witness rows total, 0 uncovered
- mcdc_ignore_classifiedPassall 63 code-level //mcdc:ignore annotation(s) are classified; capability-gap ignores reference an open KnownIssue with a failing tripwire; honored witness-row exemptions are categorized
- mcdc_known_issue_disposition_stalePassno KI-gated MC/DC or obligation disposition has outlived its fixed bug
- mcdc_verifies_witnessesPassmcdc verifies witness enforcement disabled
- mcdc_witness_drives_codePassall MC/DC witness tests reference product code and configured outcome-variable code
- mirror_completePassno mirrors declared (declare one with `proof mirror add` when starting a refactor/port)
- mirror_stalePassno mirrors declared (declare one with `proof mirror add` when starting a refactor/port)
- negative_path_witness_requiredPass0 security-classed requirement(s) carry a negative-path witness
- no_authored_change_surface_reviewedSkipdisabled by project.checks policy
- nonbool_inputs_constrainedPassno non-bool input/mode variables across 4 formalized components — every modeled input is a boolean. If any component handles quantitative values (sizes, timeouts, costs, status codes, rates), declaring them as range:/data_constraint variables unlocks Z3 verification, boundary testing, and partition evidence. See: proof help domain-modeling
- obligation_baselinePass0 requirement(s) have all 0 baseline obligation(s) resolved
- obligation_completenessPass2 stakeholder obligation checklist(s) fully covered
- obligation_decomposition_completePass46 obligation(s) on 35 requirement(s) covered by satisfying children, 14 accepted KI-debt (tripwire-backed, auto-expiring)
- obligation_delegation_resolvesPassall 1 obligation_delegations entries resolve to a target carrying the class
- obligation_enforcement_backedPassall 46 cataloged obligation checklist item(s) have signal-rule or evidence backing
- obligation_evidence_completePass62 evidence requirement(s) on 35 parent requirement(s) covered by usable evidence, 15 accepted KI-debt (tripwire-backed, auto-expiring)
- obligation_profile_evidence_completePassno evidence profiles configured
- obligation_suppression_rationalePassall 15 obligation suppression rationale(s) meet the 32-char minimum
- obligation_suppression_reviewerPassno obligation suppressions at or above reviewer-required severity
- obligation_witness_groundedPass69 witness(es): 0 grounded (static), 0 cleared (coverage), 1 exempt; 19 witness(es) coverage-unavailable (advisory)
- orphan_code_cleanPass231/231 code functions traced
- orphan_tests_cleanPass138 test functions scanned, 0 orphans
- partition_evidence_completePassno input data-constraint partitions require runtime evidence
- poc_quality_checkedPass20 in-scope known issue(s) (at or above medium severity, or being submitted) all carry a clean 11-rule PoC quality review
- problem_report_class_mitigation_evidencePassno problem reports
- problem_reports_reviewedPassno problem reports
- process_checklistPassprocess_checklist: OK — onboard_v1 complete (14 confirmed, 0 skipped, 3 not-applicable (new-project onboarding and adoption-gated steps auto-skipped)) — proof help process-checklists
- proof_complexity_cleanPassall formalized components fit proof budgets (100 reqs, 130 vars, 75 guarantees)
- property_based_test_coverageWarn18 function(s) pending property-based test evaluation
- property_fixtures_existPassno components declare fixture-backed evidence -- property fixtures not applicable
- quality_cleanPassall 87 requirements passed quality checks
- residual_kill_hygienePass2 residual(s) pass kill hygiene
- retired_cleanupPassno retired/superseded requirements
- role_prompt_hygienePassno empty-is-win or finding-quota language in 47 role(s)
- role_references_resolvePassall role references resolve (47 built-in + 0 project-local role(s) checked)
- security_relevance_consistentPass0 security-named known issue(s) carry a CVSS vector + non-none cve_surface (or a reviewer-stamped security_relevance_justification)
- security_surface_coveredSkipdisabled by project.checks policy
- signal_fixtures_validSkipdisabled by project.checks policy
- slow_tests_cleanPassslow-test audit not evaluated from shared instrumented code-level MC/DC test timings
- software_formalization_completePassall 70 review or approved guarantee requirement(s) in 1 configured lower formal-layer spec(s) have a non-envelope FRETish formalization
- solver_latency_cleanPass0 slow solver-backed components over 1m0s
- solver_modeling_opportunityPassno modeling opportunities: 85 formalized requirements evaluated, 3 carried enumerable-domain signals, all with modeled or waived domains (0 waived, 0 with recorded reasons, 3 suppressed by bool-only gate). See: proof help domain-modeling
- spec_lint_ac_inverse_coveragePasslint-ac-inverse-coverage: no issues found
- spec_lint_ac_subset_of_satisfiesPasslint-ac-subset-of-satisfies: no issues found
- spec_lint_acceptance_review_currentPasslint-acceptance-review-current: no issues found
- spec_lint_annotation_vs_authoredPasslint-annotation-vs-authored: no issues found
- spec_lint_assumption_dispositionPasslint-assumption-disposition: no issues found
- spec_lint_audit_ignore_reasonPasslint-audit-ignore-reason: no issues found
- spec_lint_auto_modifier_without_humanPasslint-auto-modifier-without-human: no issues found
- spec_lint_circularity_self_citationPasslint-circularity-self-citation: no issues found
- spec_lint_complementary_flags_uninteractedPasslint-complementary-flags-uninteracted: no issues found
- spec_lint_data_constraint_parseablePasslint-data-constraint-parseable: no issues found
- spec_lint_decomposition_adds_refinementPasslint-decomposition-adds-refinement: no issues found
- spec_lint_degenerate_input_obligation_missingPasslint-degenerate-input-obligation-missing: no issues found
- spec_lint_evidence_tag_existsPasslint-evidence-tag-exists: no issues found
- spec_lint_exemplar_missing_on_newInfolint-exemplar-missing-on-new: 40 advisory notice(s)
- spec_lint_formalization_qualityPasslint-formalization-quality: no issues found
- spec_lint_fretish_bare_responsePasslint-fretish-bare-response: no issues found
- spec_lint_fretish_tautologyPasslint-fretish-tautology: no issues found
- spec_lint_governance_yaml_data_pathsPasslint-governance-yaml-data-paths: no issues found
- spec_lint_hallucinated_symbolsPasslint-hallucinated-symbols: no issues found
- spec_lint_hazard_consequenceInfolint-hazard-consequence: 74 advisory notice(s)
- spec_lint_hazard_review_currentPasslint-hazard-review-current: no issues found
- spec_lint_id_shape_canonicalPasslint-id-shape-canonical: no issues found
- spec_lint_inline_impact_review_driftPasslint-inline-impact-review-drift: no issues found
- spec_lint_input_domain_obligation_missingPasslint-input-domain-obligation-missing: no issues found
- spec_lint_ki_attacker_coherencePasslint-ki-attacker-coherence: no issues found
- spec_lint_ki_banned_markersInfolint-ki-banned-markers: 1 advisory notice(s)
- spec_lint_ki_history_chronologyPasslint-ki-history-chronology: no issues found
- spec_lint_ki_open_actionabilityPasslint-ki-open-actionability: no issues found
- spec_lint_ki_prose_shapePasslint-ki-prose-shape: no issues found
- spec_lint_ki_stale_status_refsPasslint-ki-stale-status-refs: no issues found
- spec_lint_mediation_contract_contradictedSkipdisabled by project.checks policy
- spec_lint_na_denies_property_enforced_unevenlySkipdisabled by project.checks policy
- spec_lint_na_denies_property_the_code_managesSkipdisabled by project.checks policy
- spec_lint_numbering_gaps_has_tombstonePasslint-numbering-gaps-has-tombstone: no issues found
- spec_lint_obligation_checklist_emptyPasslint-obligation-checklist-empty: no issues found
- spec_lint_obligation_coverage_gapPasslint-obligation-coverage-gap: no issues found
- spec_lint_operational_invariant_varPasslint-operational-invariant-var: no issues found
- spec_lint_parent_field_vs_satisfiesPasslint-parent-field-vs-satisfies: no issues found
- spec_lint_pinned_delimiter_undispositionedPasslint-pinned-delimiter-undispositioned: no issues found
- spec_lint_plan_of_record_currentPasslint-plan-of-record-current: no issues found
- spec_lint_prose_ste100Passlint-prose-ste100: no issues found
- spec_lint_reject_combination_composition_witnessedPasslint-reject-combination-composition-witnessed: no issues found
- spec_lint_req_type_vs_descriptionPasslint-req-type-vs-description: no issues found
- spec_lint_review_cadence_currentPasslint-review-cadence-current: no issues found
- spec_lint_satisfies_target_retiredPasslint-satisfies-target-retired: no issues found
- spec_lint_shared_state_rebuildPasslint-shared-state-rebuild: no issues found
- spec_lint_source_doc_hedgingPasslint-source-doc-hedging: no issues found
- spec_lint_source_native_yaml_tracePasslint-source-native-yaml-trace: no issues found
- spec_lint_spec_conformance_review_groundedPasslint-spec-conformance-review-grounded: no issues found
- spec_lint_status_vs_reviewPasslint-status-vs-review: no issues found
- spec_lint_sw_informal_witnessedPasslint-sw-informal-witnessed: no issues found
- spec_lint_threat_surface_presentPasslint-threat-surface-present: no issues found
- spec_lint_trace_review_evidence_currentPasslint-trace-review-evidence-current: no issues found
- spec_lint_unjoined_effect_halvesPasslint-unjoined-effect-halves: no issues found
- spec_lint_yaml_escape_artefactPasslint-yaml-escape-artefact: no issues found
- srs_generatesPassSRS generates successfully
- srs_no_uncheckedPassall requirements checked
- stakeholder_acceptance_criteriaPass2 stakeholder reqs all have acceptance criteria with derived_reqs
- stakeholder_requirements_existPass2 stakeholder requirements found
- submission_validatedPassno active known issue has been reported externally (submission / upstream_report block) or marked for submission (disposition)
- surface_coveragePasssurface_coverage: OK — 4 surface(s) (ok=4 debt=0 gap=0 dual_gap=0 dual_residual=0) — proof help surface-coverage
- suspect_cleanPass0 suspect links
- sys_has_software_childPass15 SYS-REQ(s) have a downward realization (SW-REQ child, implementing code, or verifying tests)
- system_formalization_completePassall 15 SYS-REQs formalized in FRETish
- system_requirements_linkedPass15/15 linked to stakeholder reqs
- table_completePassno decision tables declared (domain.tables in <component>.vars.yaml); nothing to check. If any component has lookup-table or enum*action behavior (permission matrices, per-role/per-state surfaces, status transitions), declaring it under domain.tables enables completeness/consistency/equivalence checking. See: proof help domain-modeling
- table_consistentPassno decision tables declared (domain.tables in <component>.vars.yaml); nothing to check. If any component has lookup-table or enum*action behavior (permission matrices, per-role/per-state surfaces, status transitions), declaring it under domain.tables enables completeness/consistency/equivalence checking. See: proof help domain-modeling
- table_equivalencePassno decision tables declared (domain.tables in <component>.vars.yaml); nothing to check. If any component has lookup-table or enum*action behavior (permission matrices, per-role/per-state surfaces, status transitions), declaring it under domain.tables enables completeness/consistency/equivalence checking. See: proof help domain-modeling
- test_command_propagates_failurePass6 configured test command(s) propagate their real failure exit code
- tests_passPassall tests passed; linked test results from .proof/test-results/junit.xml
- trivial_lemmaPassno candidate-tautology lemmas detected
- trusted_outputs_from_untrusted_inputsPassno untrusted-input dataflows into trusted outputs: 85 formalized requirements evaluated, 0 in safety/financial scope, all sourced from trusted or sanitized data (0 waived, 0 with recorded reasons)
- under_modeled_requirements_cleanPassno requirements look under-modeled relative to current tests or implementation
- unresearched_p0_vectorsPass5 vector(s); no P0 unresearched campaigns
- vacuity_cleanPass0 vacuity findings across 85 eligible requirements
- validate_passesPass91/91 valid
- variable_driftPass1 requirement(s) have a variables: list consistent with their FRETish
- variable_orphans_cleanPass0 variable model issues
- variables_declaredPass4 formalized components passed solver preflight
- vector_campaign_closurePass5 vector(s) satisfy campaign closure (3 terminal; 2 evidence-bound; 0 KI-owned; 0 deferred-by-config)
- vector_campaign_hygienePass5 vector(s) pass campaign hygiene
- verification_chain_completePass14/14 verification chains complete
- verification_plan_evidencePassno requirements carry a verification_strategy
- verification_scope_completePassdeclared scope covers all 29 declared production source file(s)
- verification_state_consistentPass87 requirement(s) evaluated — all agree with the derived proposal
- verify_passesPassverify pipeline passed
- waivers_reviewedPassno active waivers
- z3_cross_layer_consistencyPassno comparable parent-child data-constraint partitions
- z3_properties_verifiedPassno variables with Z3-backed properties or constraints to verify